Chamber Diary

Karnataka HC Rules 2023 Amendments to Minor Mineral Rules Do Not Revive Already Rejected Quarry Applications

BENGALURU In a significant ruling clarifying the scope of statutory amendments in mining law, a division bench of the High Court of Karnataka has held that the revival of pre-2016 quarry lease applications under the Karnataka Minor Mineral Concession (Amendment) Rules, 2023, applies exclusively to applications that were pending at the time of the 2016 amendment, and does not extend to applications that had already been adjudicated and rejected prior to that date.

The judgment was rendered by a bench comprising Hon’ble Mr. Vibhu Bakhru, Chief Justice, and Hon’ble Mrs. Justice K.S. Hemalekha on November 5, 2026.

Background

The petitioner, Sri G. Ashok Kumar, had submitted an application on June 10, 2014, seeking a quarry lease for the extraction of building stone over 5.00 acres in Survey No. 185 of Marle Village, Chikkamagaluru Taluk and District.

On April 21, 2016, the Senior Geologist (Respondent No. 4) rejected the application after finding that the applied area overlapped with an existing stone quarry lease (No. 446) and another competing application (Quarry Lease Application No. 28/2014-15). The petitioner did not challenge this rejection immediately. More than two years later, in January 2019, he filed a revision petition under Rule 53(1) of the Karnataka Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1994 (KMMC Rules), which was dismissed on January 4, 2021, on the grounds of severe delay (over two years and eight months) and ineligibility under the amended Rule 8B of the 2016 Rules.

Subsequent to the Karnataka Minor Mineral Concession (Amendment) Rules, 2023, which took effect on March 17, 2023, and substituted Rule 8B to make pre-2016 applications eligible once again, the petitioner submitted multiple representations in 2023 and 2025 seeking revival and reconsideration of his 2014 application. Upon receiving no relief, he approached the High Court via a writ of mandamus.

⏳ Loading latest posts…

The core legal question before the Division Bench was whether the substitution of Rule 8B by the 2023 Amendment Rules had the legal effect of reviving applications that had already been closed and rejected prior to August 12, 2016 (the effective date of the 2016 restrictive amendments).

Analyzing the text of Rule 8B(1) as amended in 2016 and 2023, the Court observed:

  • The 2016 Threshold: The 2016 amendment rendered all applications received and pending for grant of lease prior to the commencement of those rules ineligible, subject to specific narrow exceptions.
  • The 2023 Scope: The 2023 amendment sought to revive those applications that had been rendered ineligible by virtue of being pending as of August 12, 2016.
  • Exclusion of Closed Files: The Chief Justice, writing for the bench, emphasized that because the petitioner’s application was not pending on August 12, 2016 having already been formally rejected on April 21, 2016 it was entirely unaffected by the 2016 cut-off mechanism and consequently fell outside the restorative sweep of the 2023 amendment.

The Court noted that the Revisional Authority’s earlier observation regarding Rule 8B was merely incidental and that the revision petition had been rightly rejected at the threshold for gross delay and laches.

Finding no legal basis for authorities to reopen an application that had reached finality through rejection years prior, the High Court dismissed the writ petition as devoid of merit.

Citation: Sri G. Ashok Kumar v. The State of Karnataka & Ors. | High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru | November 5, 2026 | Writ Petition No. 4956 of 2026 (GM-MM-S) 

Leave a Reply

Share on WhatsApp