The Delhi High Court has quashed the Central Government’s 2018 order directing the Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO) to investigate Educomp Solutions Limited (ESL), along with the SFIO’s investigation report and the prosecution complaint filed in 2022.
An order under Section 212(1)(c) of the Companies Act, 2013, assigning an investigation to the SFIO in the public interest, is a serious action with grave consequences and cannot be passed in a routine or mechanical manner. The Central Government’s opinion may be subjective, but the circumstances and application of mind, including why the SFIO is needed, must be demonstrable from the order itself, and cannot be supplied later through affidavits, minutes or the investigation report. Unverified complaints, forwarded letters and news reports cannot justify it when statutory inspection reports under Sections 206 and 208 found no fraud. If the initial order is invalid, the investigation report and the prosecution complaint arising from it fall with it, even after a charge-sheet or complaint is filed.
The order was a bare, three-paragraph text that only repeated the power under Section 212(1)(c) of the Companies Act, 2013 and gave no reason for choosing the SFIO. The petitioners were Vinod Kumar Dandona (independent director), Jagdish Prakash and Shantanu Prakash (promoters), the Learning Leadership Foundation, and separately former CFO Ashish Mittal. They said that the case began as a campaign by a corporate rival, the Raffles Group. The Central Government and the SFIO said that the order must be read with the Oversight Committee’s minutes of 28 June 2018, which listed the Regional Director’s inspection reports, a Member of Parliament’s complaint, PMO references, Yes Bank’s fraud monitoring report, an IFC complaint and an article in “The Wire”. Justice Amit Mahajan first rejected the plea that the petitions were barred by an earlier dismissal of a co-accused’s petition, since that was dismissed as premature, and not on merits. He then relied on Parmeshwar Das Agarwal, Nita Puri and the Supreme Court’s order of 27 January 2026 dismissing the SLP against Nita Puri, and held that the existence of circumstances for the Central Government’s opinion must be demonstrable from the order itself, and that an order cannot be improved with later reasons. Even on reading the minutes, he found that the 2017 inspection report found only compoundable irregularities, which were later compounded, the supplementary report found no fraud or diversion, Yes Bank’s complaint was already with the Delhi Police, no PMO reference was identified, and the MP’s letter and the news article had no independent value. The court said that an SFIO order is not an FIR, and that the foundation being defective, everything built on it falls. It did not decide the allegation that the article was planted by the rival, and said that it was not going into the merits of the fraud allegations.
Vinod Kumar Dandona & Ors. v. Union of India & Anr. (with Ashish Mittal v. Union of India & Ors.), W.P.(CRL) 1242/2022 and W.P.(CRL) 2970/2022, Delhi High Court (Justice Amit Mahajan), decided on 16.10.2026
Leave a Reply