Chamber Diary

Tripura HC Rules Section 232 BNSS Permits Remand Until Trial Conclusion, But Affirms It Cannot Extinguish Right to Seek Bail

AGARTALA In a comprehensive common judgment addressing both the mechanics of criminal remand under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, and the rigorous thresholds of the NDPS Act, the High Court of Tripura has held that while a Magistrate or Special Court possesses the statutory power to remand an accused until the conclusion of a trial, such an order does not foreclose or permanently bar the accused’s right to seek bail.

The ruling was delivered by Hon’ble Mr. Justice S. Datta Purkayastha on November 6, 2026, in The State of Tripura v. Sanjit Saha @ Sanju (Criminal Petition No. 46 of 2026 along with Bail Application No. 199 of 2026).

Background

The respondent-accused, Sanjit Saha @ Sanju, was arrested on October 15, 2025, following a police raid on his dwelling hut near the Mohanpur market in West Tripura, close to the Indo-Bangladesh border. According to the prosecution, the search yielded 10 blue plastic pouches containing 210 grams of Yaba tablets (a commercial quantity), alongside a factory-made pistol, an empty magazine, 16 bullets, and a Bangladeshi SIM card.

Upon completing the investigation, the police filed a charge sheet under Sections 22(C)/25/29 of the NDPS Act and Section 25(1B)(a) of the Arms Act. The Investigating Officer prayed for a “custody trial” meaning the accused should remain incarcerated throughout the trial due to the sensational nature of the offenses, proximity to the international border, and risk of absconding. On May 7, 2026, the learned Special Judge rejected the State’s prayer for custody trial, prompting the State to file a criminal petition in the High Court, which was heard alongside the accused’s regular bail application.

Legal Analysis: Scope of “Custody Trial” and Section 232 BNSS

The primary legal question examined by the High Court was whether Section 232(b) of the BNSS (corresponding to Section 209(b) of the erstwhile CrPC) empowers courts to order a custody trial that permanently shuts down an accused’s right to apply for bail.

Analyzing statutory provisions alongside Supreme Court precedents including Uday Mohanlal Acharya v. State of Maharashtra, Satender Kumar Antil v. CBI, and Kallu Nat v. State of U.P.—the High Court observed:

  • Power to Remand Until Trial Conclusion: Section 232(b) of the BNSS explicitly authorizes the Magistrate/committing court to remand an accused to custody “during, and until the conclusion of, the trial”.
  • Bail Rights Remain Intact: The Court firmly held that any such remand order is subject to the provisions of the law relating to bail. An order directing detention through the conclusion of trial cannot extinguish the constitutional and statutory right of the accused to approach the court for bail.
  • Nature of Custody Trial Petitions: The prosecution’s prayer for a “custody trial” can at best be treated as a written objection to a bail application, requiring independent judicial evaluation on a case-by-case basis rather than operating as an automatic bar.

Consequently, the High Court upheld the Special Judge’s refusal to issue an absolute, perpetual bar on bail, dismissing the State’s Criminal Petition No. 46 of 2026.

⏳ Loading latest posts…

Adjudication of the Bail Plea and the “Mini-Trial” Trap

Turning to the accused’s prayer for regular bail (Bail Application No. 199 of 2026), senior counsel for the petitioner raised multiple technical contentions:

  • Allegations of procedural flaws during search and seizure, including non-compliance with independent witness requirements under Section 103 of the BNSS.
  • Presentation of CCTV footage via an SSD, purportedly showing police personnel planting the contraband on the roof.
  • Delayed transmission of seized samples to the State Forensic Science Laboratory (SFSL) and minor discrepancies in seizure list documentation.

Rejecting these arguments at the bail stage, Justice S. Datta Purkayastha ruled that:

  1. No Mini-Trials at Bail Stage: Evaluating CCTV footage and testing the meticulous authenticity of police recoveries during a bail hearing would amount to conducting an premature “mini-trial” that prejudices the core proceedings. Matters of prejudice and procedural technicalities must be tested during the trial proper.
  2. Rigors of Section 37 NDPS Act: Given that the recovery involved a commercial quantity of Yaba tablets (210 grams), the stringent twin conditions under Section 37 of the NDPS Act were not mitigated. Official police testimony cannot be summarily discarded at this threshold without substantive trial evidence.

Conclusion

Finding no merit in the bail application, the High Court rejected both Criminal Petition No. 46 of 2026 and Bail Application No. 199 of 2026.

Recognizing that the accused had already been incarcerated for approximately one year and that 31 witnesses had been cited in the charge sheet, the Court directed the Special Judge to expedite the trial expeditiously.

Citation: The State of Tripura v. Sanjit Saha @ Sanju (Crl. Petition No. 46 of 2026 & Bail Appl. No. 199 of 2026) 2026 THC 1469 | High Court of Tripura at Agartala November 6, 2026

Leave a Reply

Share on WhatsApp