SC Settles Legislative Competence Reference on Sales Tax Surcharges, Reaffirms Landmark S. Kodar Ruling

In a landmark judgment delivered on November 4, 2026, a bench of the Supreme Court of India comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice S.V.N. Bhatti, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, Justice N.V. Anjaria, Justice Arun Palli, and a concurrent opinion by Justice K.V. Viswanathan disposed of a long-standing reference regarding the legislative competence of State Legislatures to levy a surcharge or additional sales tax calculated as a percentage of the tax payable by a dealer rather than directly on their turnover.

The Seven-Judge reference, which originated from a 1998 challenge to Section 5-A of the Orissa Sales Tax Act, 1947, and subsequently encompassed similar enactments from Punjab, has been answered by holding that the reference has been rendered infructuous/academic in light of subsequent legal developments, and that the constitutional validity of such surcharges stands firmly governed and settled by the Constitution Bench decision in S. Kodar v. State of Kerala (1974) 4 SCC 422.

1. Background

  • The Impugned Levies: The litigation arose from multiple appeals challenging state-level statutes, notably:
    • Orissa Sales Tax Act, 1947: Section 5-A (introduced via the 1990 amendment) required dealers with gross turnovers exceeding 10 lakhs to pay a 10% surcharge on the total tax payable.
    • Punjab General Sales Tax Act, 1948: Section 5(1-C) imposed a similar 10% surcharge on taxable turnover computed on the tax payable, while Section 30-AA subjected even tax-exempt industrial units to this surcharge.
  • The “Tax on Tax” Contention: Assessees argued that because the surcharge was calculated with reference to the tax payable rather than the gross or taxable turnover, it did not constitute a tax on the “sale or purchase of goods” under Entry 54 of List II of the Seventh Schedule. Instead, they contended it was an unconstitutional “tax on a tax” or a direct tax on the income/fiscal burden of the dealer.
  • The Referral Orders: In August 1998, a Two-Judge Bench felt an apparent conflict between a Three-Judge Bench decision in Hoechst Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. State of Bihar (1983) (which upheld a similar surcharge) and observations made by a Seven-Judge Bench in India Cement Ltd. v. State of Tamil Nadu (1990). In October 1999, a Five-Judge Constitution Bench noted that the foundational Constitution Bench ruling in S. Kodar would also need re-examination, leading to the constitution of a larger Bench.
⏳ Loading latest posts…

2. Core Legal Analysis by the Supreme Court

A. The True Nature of a Surcharge: Measure vs. Subject

  • The Court reiterated the well-established constitutional distinction between the subject matter of a tax (the taxable event) and the measure of a tax (the yardstick used to compute the quantum).
  • The subject of the surcharge remains the sale or purchase of goods. Computing the surcharge as a percentage of the sales tax payable is merely an arithmetical route to reach the final quantum; mathematically, a 10% surcharge on a 10% sales tax equates to a 1% additional levy on the turnover itself.
  • Citing S. Kodar and Hoechst Pharmaceuticals, the Court confirmed that such a levy is in reality an enhancement in the rate of sales tax for a class of large dealers possessing economic superiority, proportioning the tax burden to their capacity to pay. It is not a tax on income, as liability accrues based on turnover thresholds regardless of whether the dealer made a profit or suffered a loss.

B. Dispel of the Perceived Conflict with India Cement

  • The Court clarified that the tension prompting the reference was illusory. India Cement did not deal with sales tax under Entry 54 of List II; rather, it dealt with a local cess on royalty under mining laws (governed by Entry 54 of List I and Entry 23/50 of List II).
  • India Cement invalidated the cess on royalty because royalty itself was treated as a tax within an exclusively occupied parliamentary field under the MMDR Act, not because computing a levy on another impost is inherently illegal.

C. The Impact of Mineral Area Development Authority (MADA)

  • The premise of India Cement that “royalty is a tax” has been authoritatively overruled by a Nine-Judge Bench in Mineral Area Development Authority v. Steel Authority of India (2024), which held that royalty is merely a contractual consideration for mineral rights and not a tax.
  • With the foundational premise of India Cement removed, any perceived shadow or conflict over S. Kodar has completely dissolved.

D. The Altered Constitutional Landscape (GST & VAT)

  • The Court noted that the general state power to tax the sale or purchase of goods under Entry 54 of List II has since been substantially restructured by the Constitution (One Hundred and First Amendment) Act, 2016 (introducing GST via Article 246A) and prior transitions to Value Added Tax (VAT) regimes.
  • Consequently, the reference questions are of no prospective operational significance, confining the dispute strictly to legacy assessment periods.

3. Final Directions and Order

  1. Reference Answered: The reference was disposed of as having been rendered academic/infructuous, confirming that S. Kodar v. State of Kerala was correctly decided, continues to be good law, and requires no reconsideration.
  2. Specific Issues Left Open:
    • The validity of Section 30-AA of the Punjab General Sales Tax Act, 1948 (imposing surcharges on industrial units otherwise granted tax exemptions) was left open for regular benches to adjudicate on its own merits.
    • Challenges regarding the Punjab Social Security Act, 2000 (concerning whether cess proceeds can bypass the Consolidated Fund of the State under Article 266) were segregated to be heard separately by a regular Division Bench.
  3. Remand: All individual appeals relating to past assessments, periods of levy, and consequential reliefs under the Orissa and Punjab sales tax statutes were remitted back to the regular Benches of the Supreme Court to be disposed of in accordance with the law laid down in S. Kodar.

Citation: 2026 INSC 1192 (Civil Appeal No. 8763 of 1994, Arjun Flour Mills v. The State of Odisha Finance Department Secretary & Ors., pronounced on November 4, 2026). 

Leave a Reply

Share on WhatsApp