The Supreme Court has upheld the “pay minus pension” rule for retired government servants who are appointed as the Chairman or Member of the Uttarakhand Public Service Commission. It has reversed the Uttarakhand High Court, which had struck down Regulation 7(2) of the 2004 Regulations as violating “equal pay for equal work”.
A regulation that keeps the service pension of a retired government servant in abeyance, or reduces the salary of the post by the amount of pension, during his term as Chairman or Member of a Public Service Commission does not vary his conditions of service to his disadvantage under the proviso to Article 318, because the pension is only withheld and revives after the term. The principle of “equal pay for equal work” does not apply to such a deduction. A person who accepts the post with knowledge of the regulation, and challenges it only near the end of his term, is estopped by acquiescence.
Lt. Gen. (Retd.) M.C. Bhandari, who became Chairman in 2006, and Sohan Lal, a retired PCS officer who became a Member the same year, had their salaries (Rs 26,000 and Rs 22,500 respectively) reduced by their service pension, in the amounts of Rs 17,627 and Rs 11,025. After they sought redetermination, the State issued an Office Memorandum of 16 September 2008, which applied the deduction from 16 December 2004. The High Court held that the pension earned for earlier service had no connection with the duties of the PSC post, so the deduction violated Article 14 read with Article 39(d). Justices S.V.N. Bhatti and N.V. Anjaria disagreed. They held that the regulation does not reduce the pension but only holds it in abeyance during the term, and that it revives after the person leaves the PSC post. They held that “equal pay for equal work” has no application, and that adding the pension to the salary would produce absurd results, as it might exceed even the highest post’s pay. The court noted that the regulation matches Paragraph 526 of the Civil Service Regulations and the UPSC Members Regulations of 2007, and relied on Gurmesh Prakash Bishnoi for the principle of an embargo on pension during the period of re-employment. The petitioners’ argument about retrospective application of the 2008 memorandum failed, as the file notings showed a proper decision by the Governor, and in any case the regulation applied from the start. The Court also held that having accepted the posts with knowledge of the regulation, and having enjoyed the posts for over two years, they were estopped from challenging it, saying that “one who participates in a game cannot later challenge the rules of the game”. Both appeals were allowed and the High Court’s judgments set aside.
Citation: State of Uttarakhand through Chief Secretary & Others v. M.C. Bhandari & Another, Civil Appeal Nos. 1614-1615 of 2011, Supreme Court (Justices S.V.N. Bhatti and N.V. Anjaria), decided on 04.11.2026 | 2026 INSC 1194
Leave a Reply