In a comprehensive common order pronounced on November 4, 2026, the High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Jabalpur (Single Bench of Justice Pramod Kumar Agrawal) delivered rulings across a batch of interconnected petitions (M.Cr.C. Nos. 29007/2023, 44263/2023, 45021/2023, 45068/2023, 3245/2024, and Criminal Revision No. 5580/2025) arising from Crime No. 176/2022 registered at Police Station Shyamla Hills, Bhopal. The Court refused to quash the criminal proceedings and charges framed under Sections 363, 366, 366-A, 376(2)(n), 109, 120-B, and 368 of the IPC and Sections 5(i), 6, 16, and 17 of the POCSO Act against the main accused, his parents, and key relatives, while selectively granting relief to two sisters facing only omnibus allegations.
Background
- The Prosecution Case: The FIR originated from an incident on November 9, 2022, wherein a minor victim (born January 11, 2007, aged below 16 years at the time of the incident) was allegedly abducted from Bhopal and taken to Haryana by the main accused, Naveen Naara, with the active criminal conspiracy of multiple family members and associates.
- Sequential Investigation: The police filed an initial charge-sheet against Ravi Chahar on April 12, 2023. Following further investigation and subsequent statements recorded under Sections 161 and 164 of the CrPC, a supplementary charge-sheet was filed on July 21, 2023, implicating the remaining co-accused. The Special Judge (POCSO Act), Bhopal, subsequently framed charges on June 20, 2023, and August 28, 2023, prompting the petitioners to seek quashing under Section 482 CrPC and criminal revision.
Court’s Analysis
1. Immateriality of Consent for Minors
- The Court firmly reiterated that since the victim was under 16 years of age at the time of the offence, her consent carries no legal significance or evidentiary value under Section 361 of the IPC (kidnapping from lawful guardianship).
2. Prohibition of “Mini-Trials” at the Quashing Stage
- Addressing arguments regarding discrepancies, omissions, and improvements between initial and supplementary statements, the Court held that evaluating the veracity, credibility, and reasons for variations in a victim’s testimony involves disputed questions of fact. Such an exercise falls exclusively within the domain of the trial court and cannot be undertaken under Section 482 CrPC or revision.
3. Differentiation Between Active Participation and Omnibus Allegations
- Active Roles Upheld: The petitions filed by the main accused Naveen Naara, his parents (Chand Singh Pahalwan, who was aware of the victim’s age and concealed her, and Ram Pyari, who allegedly mixed intoxicants in her milk), cousin Ravi Chahar (who kept surveillance), Suman Singh (who facilitated the marriage despite knowing the age gap), Dharmendra, Ravindra, Rocky Jaat, and Anurag @ Chintu Rathi were dismissed as specific material and circumstantial evidence indicated active involvement in the conspiracy and concealment.
- Relief Granted for Uninvolved Sisters: Conversely, the Court accepted the plea on behalf of Sonika (unmarried sister) and Sarika (married sister), noting that no specific overt act or active role in the abduction or conspiracy was attributed to them, with allegations restricted solely to their presence and verbal threats at the house. Consequently, proceedings against them were quashed.
Final Verdict Summary
- Partially Allowed (M.Cr.C. No. 44263/2023): Allowed specifically regarding petitioners No. 3 and 4 (Sonika and Sarika); the charge-sheet and proceedings arising from Crime No. 176/2022 (P.S. Shyamla Hills, Bhopal) stand quashed as against them.
- Dismissed: All other petitions namely M.Cr.C. No. 29007/2023 (Ravi Chahar), M.Cr.C. No. 44263/2023 (Chand Singh Pahalwan and Ram Pyari), M.Cr.C. No. 45021/2023 (Rocky Jaat and Anurag), M.Cr.C. No. 45068/2023 (Suman Singh, Dharmendra, and Ravindra), M.Cr.C. No. 3245/2024 (Naveen Naara), and Criminal Revision No. 5580/2025 were dismissed along with the respective charge-framing orders.
Citation: Ravi Chahar v. State of M.P. and companion matters (Naveen Naara v. State of M.P.
Leave a Reply