SC Expunges Adverse Remarks and Strictures Against Rajasthan District Judge, Emphasizing Magnanimity and Natural Justice

In a judgment delivered on November 2, 2026, the Supreme Court of India allowed a Criminal Appeal setting aside and expunging all adverse remarks, strictures, and administrative directions recorded against a Judicial Officer from the District Judge Cadre of Rajasthan. The Court underscored that High Courts, acting as guardians of the district judiciary under Article 227 of the Constitution, must exercise supervisory powers with magnanimity and adhere to the principles of natural justice.

Case Background

  • The Underlying Cases: The appellant-Judicial Officer, presiding over a POCSO Court in Jhunjhunu, Rajasthan, handled two parallel trials arising out of the same FIR (FIR No. 56/2019) one against an adult co-accused (Abdul Aziz) and another against a Child in Conflict with Law (S-CNCL). Due to the statutory bar under Section 23 of the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015, barring joint proceedings, separate trials were conducted, and judgments in both matters were pronounced on January 20, 2024, convicting both accused.
  • Inadvertent Errors: While drafting the two extensive judgments, some overlapping extracts of evidence and numerical details from one trial were inadvertently incorporated into the other due to the intermingled nature of the proceedings, limited court resources, and the absence of the sole stenographer who was on leave.
  • High Court’s Strictures: While hearing an application for suspension of sentence filed by S-CNCL on May 1, 2025, a Single Judge of the Rajasthan High Court noticed the overlapping text. Without issuing notice or affording an opportunity of hearing to the Judicial Officer, the High Court criticized her use of a “cut, copy and paste” approach, recorded disparaging remarks questioning her capability, ordered a copy of the order to be sent to the Rajasthan Judicial Academy for training, and directed that it be made part of her Annual Confidential Report (ACR).
  • Appeal to the Supreme Court: Aggrieved by these unexpunged strictures, the Judicial Officer approached the Apex Court.

Court’s Analysis

1. Violation of the Principles of Natural Justice (Audi Alteram Partem)

  • The Supreme Court held that the strictures and adverse observations recorded by the High Court on the judicial side suffered from a fundamental flaw: they were passed without affording any opportunity to the appellant-Judicial Officer to show cause or explain the circumstances under which the clerical errors occurred. This direct condemnation violated the cardinal rule of audi alteram partem.

2. High Courts as Guardians of the District Judiciary

  • Invoking ancient and global philosophical tenets on human fallibility and forgiveness (“To err is human, to forgive, divine” and “Kshama Virasya Bhushanam”), the bench stressed that the supervisory jurisdiction of High Courts under Article 227 is meant to guide, strengthen, and nurture the district judiciary, rather than castigate officers for bona fide typographical errors that did not alter the substantive outcome of the trial.
  • The Court noted that POCSO courts often function under immense pressure with limited resources and heavy caseloads, making minor clerical oversights possible without implying dereliction of duty.

3. Proper Channel for Administrative Concerns

  • Re-affirming recent precedents (Kaushal Singh v. State of Rajasthan and Shuvendu Saha v. State of West Bengal), the Supreme Court reiterated that when a High Court notices defects or quality issues in a trial judge’s work, the appropriate course is to record observations in a remark slip placed before the Chief Justice or Administrative Judge on the administrative side, where the officer can submit an explanation. Condemning a judge’s personal conduct on the judicial side without notice destroys careers and exerts a chilling effect on the entire district judiciary.

Final Directions

  • Appeal Allowed: The appeal was allowed.
  • Strictures Expunged: Adverse remarks and observations contained in paragraphs 9, 10, and 11 of the High Court’s order dated May 1, 2025, along with the directions regarding training and placement in her ACR (paragraphs 17 and 18), were completely expunged and set aside.
  • Administrative Transmission: The Registry was directed to transmit a copy of the order to the Registrar General of the Rajasthan High Court to be placed before the Hon’ble Chief Justice.
⏳ Loading latest posts…

Citation: In Re: XXX, A Judicial Officer (2026 INSC 1188)

Leave a Reply

Share on WhatsApp