Rajasthan HC Full Bench: Writ Petitions arising out of or concerning Criminal matters are Maintainable u/Article 226 Prospectively

In a significant full bench decision delivered on November 2, 2026, the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jaipur (comprising Chief Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal, Justice Sameer Jain, and Justice Anuroop Singhi) answered D.B. Civil Reference No. 2/2026. The Full Bench held that writ petitions arising out of or concerning criminal matters are maintainable under Article 226 of the Constitution and must be separately registered and processed as “Criminal Writ Petitions” pursuant to Rule 315(1)(h) of the Rajasthan High Court Rules, 1952. The Court formally ruled that the contrary directions issued by a Division Bench in Jiya & Others v. The Government of Rajasthan & Others (July 7, 2026) which prohibited criminal-side writ registration were rendered per incuriam for failing to consider express statutory rules.

Background

  • The Conflict: While hearing a civil writ petition, a Single Bench (Anand Sharma, J.) noticed a sharp procedural conflict. On July 7, 2026, a Division Bench in Jiya v. State of Rajasthan (D.B. Criminal Writ Petition No. 128/2018) had directed that the Registry should no longer register any case under the nomenclature “Criminal Writ Petition,” holding that the Constitution contains no separate category known as a “Criminal Writ Petition” and that all petitions involving criminal matters must be treated exclusively as civil writ petitions.
  • The Statutory Rule: Conversely, Rule 315(1)(h) of the Rajasthan High Court Rules, 1952 (framed under Section 46 of the Rajasthan High Court Ordinance, 1949, read with Article 225) explicitly mandates that applications for the issue of a writ under Article 226 in a criminal matter shall be registered and numbered under the criminal miscellaneous framework.
  • The Reference Questions: Finding an irreconcilable clash between the Division Bench’s administrative-judicial diktat in Jiya and the mandatory command of Rule 315(1)(h), the Single Bench referred five questions of law to a Full Bench to resolve procedural uncertainty across the Bar and the Registry.

Full Bench Analysis

1. Mandatory Force of Rule 315(1)(h)

  • The Full Bench emphasized that Rule 315(1)(h) is an express procedural provision carrying the force of law, placing writ applications in criminal matters on par with core criminal proceedings like bail, cancellation of bail, and transfer applications.
  • A judicial direction or order concerning case nomenclature cannot render a statutory rule inoperative or bypass it without lawfully declaring the rule unconstitutional or ultra vires.

2. Constitutional Distinction Between Civil and Criminal Proceedings

  • Relying on Supreme Court precedents including Ram Kishan Fauji v. State of Haryana (2017) and Narayan Row, the Full Bench reiterated that the Constitution distinctly recognizes both civil and criminal proceedings (e.g., Articles 133 and 134).
  • Criminal proceedings encompass actions that may result in penal sentences (imprisonment, fine, forfeiture) or preventive orders aimed at maintaining public peace and order. The procedural classification must reflect the substantive nature of the dispute, the right violated, and the relief sought.

3. Jiya Decision Declared Per Incuriam

  • The Full Bench held that the directions in Jiya failed to account for or give effect to the mandatory statutory mandate of Rule 315(1)(h).
  • Applying the doctrine of per incuriam (as crystallized in State of U.P. v. Synthetics and Chemicals Ltd.), the Court ruled that a decision rendered in ignorance of a binding statutory rule cannot eclipse the legislative and administrative framework established under the High Court Rules.
⏳ Loading latest posts…

Directions

The Full Bench answered the reference by holding that criminal-matter writ petitions must be registered and listed on the criminal side, issuing comprehensive prospective directions:

  1. Prospective Operation: The declaration of law operates prospectively from November 2, 2026, ensuring that all previously concluded judgments and final orders remain undisturbed.
  2. Mandatory Registry Registration: The Registry is directed to entertain, register, and process writ petitions arising out of criminal matters under the exact nomenclature of “Criminal Writ Petition” pursuant to Rule 315(1)(h).
  3. Re-registration of Pending Matters: Pending writ petitions arising from criminal matters that were erroneously registered under alternative nomenclatures must be re-registered as “Criminal Writ Petitions” within two weeks and placed before the appropriate roster bench.
  4. Administrative Implementation: The Registrar (Judicial) was directed to issue uniform administrative instructions immediately to eliminate procedural ambiguity across the principal seat at Jodhpur and the Jaipur Bench.

Citation: Ravi Kumar v. State of Rajasthan (D.B. Civil Reference No. 2/2026, 2026:RJ-JP:44204-DB)

Leave a Reply

Share on WhatsApp