The Madhya Pradesh High Court (Indore Bench) has ordered the bank account of a petitioner, Narendra, to be unfrozen in a cyber-fraud case. It has directed that only the disputed Rs 22,000 be kept in a fixed deposit, applying its earlier rulings that bar a blanket freeze of an entire account over a small disputed amount.
Freezing of an entire bank account is an extraordinary measure that must satisfy the test of proportionality, and the police should ordinarily restrict the freeze or lien to the disputed amount, with the freezing of the full account only for reasons recorded in writing. The bank must act as the first point of contact for grievances under the MHA’s SOP of 10 April 2026, and the authorities must follow the time limits strictly, which are the outer limits and not the ordinary period. If the freeze remains unresolved for 90 days without a lawful direction to continue it, the account can be released after notice to the police, and a writ petition ordinarily lies after that period.
Narendra’s account had been frozen on the instructions of a cyber crime cell, though only a small sum was said to be linked to fraud. His counsel relied on the Malcolm Murayis v. State Bank of India ruling of 2024, which said that the disputed amount should be placed in a fixed deposit, to be released only after the Magistrate’s orders within three months. After that ruling, the Ministry of Home Affairs issued a Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) on 10 April 2026, on grievances against accounts put on hold through the NCRP-CFCFRMS system. A coordinate Bench at Jabalpur in Archana v. State of M.P. (27 July 2026) framed guidelines for it. Justice Sandeep N. Bhatt reproduced them and applied both rulings. The main guidelines are that the police should ordinarily put a lien or debit freeze only on the disputed amount, and freeze the entire account only for recorded reasons in exceptional cases. The police must tell the Magistrate of the freeze “as soon as reasonably possible”, and banks must keep full records, tell the account holder of the freeze and upload a grievance on the portal within seven days. The Investigating Officer must decide the grievance in 15 days, with automatic escalation to the District Grievance Redressal Officer, and the bank must release the hold within 48 hours of a release order. If a grievance remains unresolved for 90 days, the bank can release the hold after giving 15 days’ notice to the police. A writ petition ordinarily lies after the 90 days, but not as an absolute bar. In Archana, the suspicious amount was Rs 980 against a balance of over Rs 2.5 crore. Here, the court ordered the account to be unfrozen with the disputed Rs 22,000 in a fixed deposit, to be released only on the Magistrate’s orders within three months, failing which the petitioner can withdraw it.
Citation: Narendra v. Branch Manager (and others), Writ Petition No. 45934 of 2026, Madhya Pradesh High Court, Indore Bench (Justice Sandeep N. Bhatt), decided on 04.11.2026 | 2026:MPHC-IND:31350
Leave a Reply