In a judgment delivered on November 7, 2026, the Court of the IInd Additional Sessions Judge, Dehradun (Presided by Shri Mahesh Chandra Kaushiwa, H.J.S.) acquitted the accused Sarthak Chhillar in Sessions Trial No. 138 of 2024 arising from Crime No. 96 of 2024 of Police Station Prem Nagar. The trial court held that the prosecution miserably failed to establish the charges under Sections 147, 148, 323, 324, 325, 504, 506, and 307 read with Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) beyond reasonable doubt, extending the absolute benefit of doubt to the accused.
Background
- The Incident: On May 3, 2024, between 5:00 p.m. and 6:00 p.m., the informant/injured Vishal Chaudhary (a law student at UPES, Dehradun) was dining with his classmate Ginika Singh at Thakur Restaurant in Kandoli, Dehradun. Two vehicles (including a Hyundai Verna bearing registration no. DL-11-CD-3609) arrived, and 8 to 10 individuals allegedly launched a sudden murderous assault from behind using swords, sharp-edged weapons, pistols, and sticks.
- The informant named Mr. Sarthak Chhillar, his brother Mr. Anurag (Samrat) Chhillar, and Mr. Abhigyan Rana as perpetrators, attributing the motive to previous college animosity. An FIR (No. 96/2024) was registered on May 7, 2024. Following investigation, a charge-sheet was submitted solely against Sarthak Chhillar, and charges were framed by the Court under Sections 147, 148, 323, 324, 325, 504, 506, and 307 read with Section 149 IPC.
Proceedings:-
- Prosecution Witnesses: The prosecution examined 12 witnesses, including injured witness PW-4 Vishal Chaudhary, medical experts (PW-2, PW-3, PW-5, PW-10), police investigators (PW-6, PW-7, PW-8), and local/companion witnesses.
- Section 311 Cr.P.C. Recall: Following the conclusion of defense arguments, the prosecution belatedly invoked Section 311 Cr.P.C. to summon additional witnesses, bringing on record Vishant (PW-11) and Ms. Ginika Singh (PW-12).
- Defense Stand: The accused denied all allegations under Section 313 Cr.P.C., maintaining total innocence and asserting that the case was a retaliatory counter-blast fabricated to pressure him into compromising an active criminal case (FIR Crime No. 245/2023) which he had earlier registered against the informant for a brutal physical assault in December 2023.
Court’s Analysis
1. Unreliable Identification and Masked Assailants
- While acknowledging that the testimony of an injured witness (PW-4 Vishal Chaudhary) carries weight, the Court emphasized that where embedded contradictions and prior enmity exist, such testimony must be scrutinized with extreme care and caution, in line with Supreme Court precedents (Devinder v. State of Haryana, Laxman v. State of Maharashtra, and State of M.P. v. Mishrilal).
- Direct Contradiction: PW-4’s claim of identifying Sarthak Chhillar was completely demolished by his own companion, PW-12 (Ms. Ginika Singh), and PW-11 (Vishant), both of whom testified that all the attackers had completely covered their faces with cloth and masks, making identification impossible. Furthermore, the restaurant proprietor, PW-9 (Smt. Vimla), testified that the accused was not present at the scene.
2. Medical Evidence vs. Ocular Claims (Failure of Section 307 IPC)
- Weapon Inconsistency: PW-4 alleged the use of lethal weapons like swords and pistols. However, medical evidence (PW-10) and radiological reports (Material Exhibit MO-2) confirmed only a blunt scalp laceration and a classic defensive “nightstick fracture” of the left ulnar shaft, with zero incised, puncture, or ballistic wounds.
- No Homicidal Intent: The Non-Contrast Computed Tomography (NCCT) head scan revealed zero skull fractures or intracranial bleeding, noting strictly soft tissue swelling. Citing State of Maharashtra v. Kashirao and Parsuram Pandey v. State of Bihar, the Court held that a defensive forearm fracture and superficial scalp swelling cannot sustain a grave charge of an attempt to murder under Section 307 IPC.
3. Investigation Lapses, Adverse Inference, and Prior Enmity
- Suppression of Evidence: The prosecution failed to preserve or produce alleged mobile video recordings or CCTV footage despite availability, inviting an adverse inference under Section 114(g) of the Indian Evidence Act (Tomaso Bruno v. State of U.P.).
- Motive for False Implication: The defense successfully established that the accused had previously lodged FIR No. 245/2023 against the informant PW-4 for a December 2023 assault. This deep-rooted enmity provided a potent motive for retaliatory false implication (Ramashish Rai v. Jagdish Rai).
- Procedural Flaw in Medical Board: The Court reiterated severe administrative irregularities, noting that the Senior Superintendent of Police (SSP), Dehradun, lacked statutory authority to directly constitute a Medical Board (Ex. P-1) without routing the request through the Chief Medical Officer (CMO).
Final Decision
- Acquittal: The Court held that the prosecution failed to bridge the gap between “may be true” and “must be true”. Accused Sarthak Chhillar is hereby acquitted of all charges under Sections 147, 148, 323, 324, 325, 307, 504, and 506 read with Section 149 IPC by extending the benefit of doubt.
- Bail Bonds & Compliance: Personal and bail bonds of the accused are discharged, subject to compliance with Section 437-A Cr.P.C. (keeping bonds active for six months for potential appellate proceedings).
Citation: State of Uttarakhand v. Sarthak Chhillar (Sessions Trial No. 138 of 2024)
Leave a Reply