Report of Handwriting Expert Isn’t Admissible Under Section 293 CrPC Without Examining Expert: SC Sets Aside Ten-Year Sentence Under Section 306 IPC

The Supreme Court has acquitted a Jaipur man who had been sentenced to ten years for abetting his estranged wife’s suicide, because the prosecution never properly proved that he wrote the abusive letters it relied on, and even if he did, they did not amount to abetment.

A handwriting expert’s report is opinion evidence that must be proved by examining the expert in court, and it is not admissible under Section 293 CrPC (now Section 329 BNSS). Where the specimen writings for comparison are not themselves proved, and there is no corroboration, a conviction cannot rest on it. The failure of an accused to deny authorship in his Section 313 statement does not relieve the prosecution of its burden. For abetment of suicide under Sections 306 and 107 IPC, there must be instigation, or an act that leaves the victim no alternative but to end her life, and abusive or threatening words, read in context, do not by themselves amount to it.

The couple married in 1996 and had a son. In February 2009, she left the matrimonial home and later filed a dowry harassment case and a domestic violence case, in which she sought maintenance. She set herself on fire at her parental home on 18 January 2011 and died the same day. Her mother lodged a complaint on 2 February 2011, and the police registered an FIR under Section 306 IPC. The prosecution relied mainly on four postcard letters allegedly written by the husband, containing abusive language and threats to kill her. The trial court and the Rajasthan High Court accepted them and convicted him. Justices Sandeep Mehta and Devendra Kumar Upadhyaya allowed his appeal. They noted that the police never took his specimen handwriting, and used for comparison only an application he had allegedly handed to the officer at his arrest and a pocket diary produced by his brother. Without proof of those writings, the expert’s report could not decide authorship. The expert was not examined, and, relying on Magan Bihari Lal and Patel Babubhai Manohardas, a handwriting expert’s report is not admissible under Section 293 CrPC and must be proved by examining the expert so that he can be cross-examined. The accused’s failure to deny authorship in his Section 313 statement could not fill the gap. The court also found no proof that the letters caused her to commit suicide, as the witnesses did not mention them in the inquest, the complaint came 15 days after her death, and no charge under Section 498-A was framed. Even if he wrote them, the letters, read as a whole, also appealed to her to withdraw the cases and return, and since she had lived away for over two years, they were not “instigating material” under Sections 306 and 107 IPC. The court also noted that the contemporaneous police and hospital entries mentioned an electric short circuit and a gas cylinder, and the FSL found no smell of kerosene.

Citation: Goverdhan v. State of Rajasthan, Criminal Appeal No. 1394 of 2017, Supreme Court (Justices Sandeep Mehta and Devendra Kumar Upadhyaya), decided on 03.11.2026 | 2026 INSC 1190

Leave a Reply

Share on WhatsApp