When Legislation Overtakes Antitrust: CCI Recalls Google Investigation Following the Enactment of the Online Gaming Act, 2025

Case: Winzo Games Private Limited v. Google LLC & Ors. (Case No. 42 of 2022)

In a landmark decision that underscores the intersection of digital market regulation and overarching legislative changes, the Competition Commission of India (CCI) has officially closed its high-profile antitrust inquiry against Google. The proceedings—sparked by an information filed by digital gaming platform WinZo over restrictive Google Play Store and Google Ads policies—were rendered legally infructuous following Parliament’s enactment of the Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act, 2025.

By exercising its inherent powers under Section 36(1) of the Competition Act, 2002, the CCI recalled its earlier prima facie investigation order, establishing a crucial precedent on how regulatory bodies should manage ongoing antitrust proceedings when the legislature entirely occupies and criminalizes the underlying market.

Background: The Genesis of the Dispute

The litigation commenced in 2022 when WinZo Games Private Limited approached the CCI alleging that Google LLC, Alphabet Inc., and its Indian subsidiaries abused their dominant position under Section 4 of the Competition Act.

The core grievances centered on:

1. The Play Store RMG Pilot: Google’s policy restricted Real-Money Games (RMGs) globally, except for a selective 1-year Pilot Program launched in India in late 2022 that was arbitrarily limited exclusively to Daily Fantasy Sports (DFS) and Rummy.

2. Discriminatory Advertising Policy: Google restricted its Google Ads platform to only allow DFS and Rummy app developers to advertise, starving competing skill-based gaming platforms of vital market visibility.

3. Arbitrary Payment Warnings: Google Pay displayed unsettling warning prompts when users attempted to execute transactions for WinZo’s skill-based games.

Finding merit in these arguments, the CCI passed a prima facie order under Section 26(1) on November 28, 2024, directing the Director General (DG) to launch a comprehensive antitrust investigation into Google across licensable OS, app store, and search advertising markets.

During the pendency of the probe, Google invoked Section 48B of the Competition Act, opting for the statutory commitment mechanism. After initial rejections, Google submitted a Second Revised Commitment Application on June 23, 2025. Under this proposal, Google committed to:

Open Google Play to all legally permissible online RMGs based on third party certification of skill.

Permit advertisements for all compliant RMG apps on Google Ads.

Wind down the restrictive Pilot Program once the framework rolled out.

The CCI accepted the proposal for public market-testing in July 2025 and placed the antitrust investigation in abeyance.

However, before the commitments could take final effect, the legal landscape transformed dramatically. On August 22, 2025, the Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act, 2025 received presidential assent, coming into force alongside its governing rules on May 1, 2026.

The Impact of the Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act, 2025

The new legislation completely restructured the digital gaming ecosystem by enforcing a game-neutral, blanket prohibition:

Section 5 criminalizes offering, aiding, or engaging in online money games and gaming services, regardless of whether a game is classified as a “game of skill” or “game of chance”.

Section 6 bans all advertisements that directly or indirectly promote online money games.

Section 7 prohibits financial institutions and payment gateways from facilitating monetary transactions toward online money gaming services.

Realizing that the new statute rendered its commitment offer legally impossible to execute, Google moved the CCI to close the proceedings. Meanwhile, WinZo itself sought to voluntarily withdraw its information, citing the supervening change in law.

Key Legal Findings by the CCI

In its detailed closure order, the Commission addressed several vital procedural and substantive principles:

1. Infructuous Nature of the Relevant Market:

Because the Online Gaming Act established a complete, uniform ban on RMGs, no lawful RMG market exists anymore. Consequently, the foundation of the CCI’s original market distortion concerns evaporated, as granting the relief sought by WinZo (forcing Google to host all RMGs and run their ads) would directly violate federal law.

2. Inquisitorial Character vs. Dominus Litis:

The CCI reiterated that antitrust proceedings are in rem (affecting the public at large) and inquisitorial. An informant is not the dominus litis (master of the suit) who can dictate the life or death of a case. However, WinZo’s withdrawal accurately signaled that no individual relief survived.

3. Application of Inherent Powers (Section 36(1)):

Citing precedents like Kedar Nath Agrawal v. Dhanraji Devi and its powers to recall administrative directions under Section 26(1) (as affirmed in Google Inc. v. CCI by the Delhi High Court), the Commission held that continuing an academic inquiry into a now-prohibited economic activity would waste limited regulatory resources.

4. Precautionary Caveat:

The CCI explicitly noted that its closure is strictly tied to the legal framework prevailing on the date of the order. Should the constitutional challenges pending before the Supreme Court against the Online Gaming Act result in the statute being struck down or stayed, the CCI reserved full liberty to revive its oversight.

Conclusion

The closure of Case No. 42 of 2022 serves as a textbook study on regulatory subordination to statutory law. Key takeaways for competition law practitioners include:

Primacy of Parliament: Antitrust enforcement cannot override explicit legislative prohibitions. When a statutory ban occupies an entire market, competition remedies become legally non-implementable.

Commitment Mechanics in Flux: The case highlights the vulnerability of the CCI’s commitment framework when macro-regulatory environments shift mid-proceeding.

Proactive Compliance: Google’s preemptive steps in winding down its RMG Pilot Program and ad permissions ahead of the May 2026 enforcement date shielded it from further statutory liability.

The constitutional validity of the Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act, 2025 remains sub judice before the Hon’ble Supreme Court, promising further twists in India’s digital gaming jurisprudence.

Leave a Reply

Share on WhatsApp