Section 106 Evidence Act Burden on Husband to Explain Strangulation Inside Matrimonial Home: SC Upholds Life Sentence for Husband and Dowry Death Convictions of Father-in-Law and Brother-in-Law

The Supreme Court has upheld the life sentence of a Nanded husband for strangling his wife nine months after their marriage, rejecting his claim that she died from an epileptic fit during sexual intercourse. It has also upheld the dowry death convictions of his father and brother.

Where a death takes place inside a house, and the accused was in the exclusive company of the deceased, the prosecution’s burden to prove guilt through circumstantial evidence is lighter, and the accused must give a cogent explanation under Section 106 of the Evidence Act. A false defence adds a link to the chain of circumstances. Where unnatural death occurs within seven years of marriage and cruelty or harassment over dowry demands “soon before” death is proved, the presumption under Section 113-B of the Evidence Act arises and the accused must rebut it.

The husband, Ramkishan Jadhav, married Vimalbai on 12 May 1995, and she died at the matrimonial home in the early hours of 1 February 1996. The prosecution said that she was harassed and starved over demands for Rs 50,000 in cash, a television set, a tape deck and a plot of land in the MIDC area, and that on one occasion she was tied with a rope and lowered into a well with a threat of death. Before her brother’s complaint, the husband had given an application to the police saying that she suddenly felt giddy and her jaws locked while they were having sexual intercourse, and died. The post-mortem found “asphyxia due to throttling”, with a fractured hyoid bone and bruises on the neck. The trial court convicted the husband, his father (Digambar) and his brother (Venkat) under Sections 498-A and 304-B read with Section 34 IPC, but acquitted all of them of murder. The Bombay High Court at Aurangabad reversed the husband’s acquittal in 2013 and sentenced him to life under Section 302 IPC. Justices Sandeep Mehta and Devendra Kumar Upadhyaya dismissed the appeals. They found the defence false, since the medical jurist denied that there was any lock-jaw or tongue displacement, or that such neck injuries could result from an epileptic fit. Since the death took place inside the privacy of the home, where the husband was in the exclusive company of his wife, Section 106 of the Evidence Act required him to explain how she died, and his false explanation added a link to the chain of circumstances (Trimukh Maroti Kirkan). On dowry death, the evidence of her brother, father, the mediator and two independent neighbours proved persistent cruelty over dowry demands soon before her death, and the accused did not rebut the presumption under Section 113-B. The father-in-law’s appeal abated since he died during the appeal. The remaining appellants must surrender within four weeks to serve the rest of their sentences.

⏳ Loading latest posts…

Citation: Ramkishan Digambar Jadhav v. State of Maharashtra (with connected Criminal Appeal No. 962 of 2014), Criminal Appeal No. 1849 of 2013, Supreme Court (Justices Sandeep Mehta and Devendra Kumar Upadhyaya), decided on 02.11.2026 | 2026 INSC 1187 (Non-Reportable)

Leave a Reply

Share on WhatsApp