In a Criminal Revision, the Court of the Additional Sessions Judge, Dehradun, presided over by Shri Mahesh Chandra Kaushiwa (H.J.S.), exercised its revisional jurisdiction under Section 397(1) read with Section 438(1) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023 in a Section 138 Negotiable Instruments Act matter to set aside an impugned trial court order that had refused defense documents on hyper-technical grounds, formally directing the lower court to treat the defense documents as validly and continuously existing on the judicial record.
Background
The underlying matter arises from a Section 138 Negotiable Instruments Act complaint case (No. 3535 of 2021) pending before the ACJM-I (Special NI Act Court), Dehradun, which is currently at the stage of defense evidence. The revisionist-accused intended to rely on defense documents submitted via schedules dated November 5, 2024, October 21, 2024, and November 30, 2024.
Following initial rejections and a prior consent-based revisional order dated July 17, 2025 (Criminal Revision No. 109 of 2025), the trial court permitted the accused on March 24, 2026, to physically substitute original documents with certified copies. However, via an order dated July 15, 2026, the trial court partially rejected the accused’s application, holding that the original document lists “ceased to exist on record” because they were physically withdrawn during the intermediate substitution process.
Observations of the Revisional Court
The Additional Sessions Judge strongly criticized the trial court’s approach, outlining several critical legal principles for trial courts handling documentary evidence:
- Rejection of Hyper-Technicality: The court ruled that treating documents as extinguished due to an administrative substitution order is a “glaring exercise in hyper-technicality” and a “procedural trap”.
- “Handmaid of Justice” Doctrine: Reaffirming established jurisprudence, the court emphasized that procedural rules are designed to serve as a handmaid of justice, not a minefield deployed to defeat substantive rights.
- Binding Nature of Consent Orders: The Revisional Court underscored that a prior consent order dated July 17, 2025, carried a binding judicial mandate that neither party nor the lower court could evade through subsequent technical maneuvers.
- Protection of Fair Trial Rights: The judgment reiterates that an accused possesses an absolute, unalienable right to a fair trial and a complete opportunity to build a defense, which cannot be eroded by mechanical procedural constraints.
Final Directions
The Sessions Court allowed the criminal revision, formally setting aside the trial court’s July 15, 2026 order. Key directives issued by the court include:
- The defense documents filed under the specific 2024 schedules are mandated to remain continuously and validly on the judicial record for exhibition, examination-in-chief, and cross-examination without requiring fresh applications.
- A reciprocal opportunity has been granted to the complainant to lead rebuttal evidence in accordance with the law.
- Both parties are directed to cooperate for expeditious disposal without unnecessary adjournments.
Leave a Reply